Skip to main content

The Best Small Batch Bourbon from the 2025 New York World Spirits Competition

The Best Small Batch Bourbon from the 2025 New York World Spirits Competition
The Tasting Alliance Team
10.20.25

The New York World Spirits Competition continues to celebrate craftsmanship and character in every pour — and few categories capture that spirit like small batch bourbon. This year’s finalists impressed judges with their balance, depth, and individuality, but one stood above the rest for its complexity and expressive flavor.

Winner: Peg Leg Porker Spirits – Grey Label Tennessee Straight Bourbon

Founded by award-winning pitmaster Carey Bringle, Peg Leg Porker Spirits brings the soul of Tennessee barbecue to the world of bourbon. Known for its meticulous approach and dedication to Southern tradition, the brand has built a cult following among whiskey enthusiasts who appreciate bold flavors and authenticity.

The Grey Label Tennessee Straight Bourbon represents the pinnacle of the Peg Leg Porker portfolio — a rich, full-bodied whiskey that exemplifies the brand’s signature style. Made with a carefully selected mash bill and aged to perfection, it delivers both elegance and depth in every sip. This standout bourbon’s intricate layers and impeccable balance captured the attention of judges, earning it the title of Best Small Batch Bourbon at the 2025 New York World Spirits Competition.

An expressive bourbon that opens with vibrant aromas of grape jelly, cherry, cashews, brown sugar, and bright notes of orange peel, leading to a balanced and luscious palate where fruity sweetness melds with chocolate, oak, and creamy vanilla fudge, complemented by hints of brown sugar, citrus, and black tea, and finishing long and complex with refreshing touches of orange, mint, and marzipan for a sweet, lasting finish.

2025 New York World Spirits Competition Judging Panel

Finalist: Barrell Batch 037 Bourbon

A name synonymous with innovation and transparency, Barrell Craft Spirits continues to redefine the art of blending with each release. Known for its cask-strength expressions and meticulous sourcing, Barrell’s small batch bourbons are crafted to showcase nuance and individuality rather than uniformity.

Batch 037 exemplifies that philosophy. The blend highlights a harmony of well-aged barrels, yielding a bourbon that’s both refined and robust — a testament to Barrell’s blending expertise.

An elegantly crafted bourbon with a nose of toasted pecan and fresh apple layered subtly with hints of sawdust, unfolding on the palate with smooth barley and rich, Cognac-like depth, culminating in a long, hot finish that balances intensity with refined sophistication.

2025 New York World Spirits Competition Judging Panel

The 2025 finalists prove that small batch bourbon remains a space where artistry and individuality thrive — a celebration of precision, patience, and passion in American whiskey making.

EDIT